This "new economy" is going to create some wonderful opportunities for the fire service. Let me explain. There's an old saying that goes something like this "You don't worry about where your next meal will come from when your belly is full." In other words, it's the hunger that drives our instinct to "hunt" for food. Budget cuts will mean there will be less food (money), forcing us to go on a hunt for new and creative ways to survive.
This can be a good thing because it will force fire administrators to look at solutions that before were not attractive. Again, back to my example, if you're not hungry, ants may not look like a tasty treat. But if you are starving, you may eat it (and might even enjoy them... I hear they're quite good when covered in chocolate). But if you are never forced to consider ants as a meal choice, you're far less likely to even consider them an option.
A fire department who has been able to survive on the budget plan that next year's budget will be equal to this year's budget plus 3% is in for a rude awakening. The new economy is going to force them to go on the hunt for new ways of doing business. What do I mean? Here's an example.
Let's say there's a fire alarm activation in a high school during school hours. Logic (and experience). Using my high school as an example (enrollment of about 2,500). There are no less than 1,000 cell phones in that school (my kids contribute 3 of them). If there is an actual fire in the school, the 9-1-1 phones are going to light up like a Christmas tree. So why is it that some fire departments send 3 engines, 2 ladders, 2 chiefs, a boat and a helicopter (ok, maybe a slight exaggeration... maybe they don't send the boat) to a fire alarm activation at a fully occupied high school. Send one company. If you get additional calls, upgrade. Controversial? Perhaps. But this type of response is, in my opinion, excessive and expensive. Helps to keep the numbers up and justify the staffing levels, for sure. But those staffing levels are going to change in this new economy and departments are going to be forced to hunt for new ways to do business.
Regionalization of services, consolidations, mergers, cooperative ventures... all on the table. Some years ago (age won't allow me to remember the year) we were going through some tough economic times and I wrote an article where I noted the tough economy will force departments to do things in new ways. Unfortunately, the economy turned around quickly and everyone was able to recover before they changed or starved and it was back to business as usual.
I am far less optimistic that this economy will turn around as quickly and we are all going to be forced to go on the hunt for new and innovative ways to survive... and thrive.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
www.RichGasaway.com
This commentary was also posted on the Fire Service Chief Officer's Group on LinkedIn. My thanks to the visionary leadership of Fire Chief George Esbensen (Eden Prairie, Minnesota) for starting this group. I encourage you to join in the discussion here and there. Sharing thoughts and ideas makes all of us smarter.
Showing posts with label consolidations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consolidations. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 31, 2008
Thursday, December 4, 2008
Finding the good in a bad economy
We are officially in a recession. Now what? Companies are laying off record numbers of workers. Now what? State and local governments are predicting huge deficits. Now what?
As tax revenues decline, local governments will be forced to reduce budgets. This can result in significant challenges to the providers of local government services, especially those who provide essential services.
Fire departments who have done the same thing the same way for a long period of time may find it difficult to find creative solutions in these difficult times. However difficult it it may be, fire department leaders must break out of the "that's the way we've always done it" mold and think creatively. I know of no vocation that is required to be more creative on a regular basis than the fire service. However, you are used to solving other people's problems and this time the problem is yours.
It is harder to solve a problem when you are emotionally attached to it. No fire department wants to cut any services that dedicated personnel have worked so hard to provide. No fire department wants to see members receive a pay raise that does not keep pace with inflation. No fire department wants to merge with a neighboring department and risk giving up their identity. But all these things are on the table.
Challenging economic times like these do not create character, but such times will expose the character of your members and challenge your leadership. I encourage you to be strong, principled, rational, and above all else, open-minded as you look for innovative ways to weather this stormy economy.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
As tax revenues decline, local governments will be forced to reduce budgets. This can result in significant challenges to the providers of local government services, especially those who provide essential services.
Fire departments who have done the same thing the same way for a long period of time may find it difficult to find creative solutions in these difficult times. However difficult it it may be, fire department leaders must break out of the "that's the way we've always done it" mold and think creatively. I know of no vocation that is required to be more creative on a regular basis than the fire service. However, you are used to solving other people's problems and this time the problem is yours.
It is harder to solve a problem when you are emotionally attached to it. No fire department wants to cut any services that dedicated personnel have worked so hard to provide. No fire department wants to see members receive a pay raise that does not keep pace with inflation. No fire department wants to merge with a neighboring department and risk giving up their identity. But all these things are on the table.
Challenging economic times like these do not create character, but such times will expose the character of your members and challenge your leadership. I encourage you to be strong, principled, rational, and above all else, open-minded as you look for innovative ways to weather this stormy economy.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
Thursday, November 20, 2008
ISO Proposing Changes
ISO is FINALLY proposing changes to their fire protection rating schedule. Their existing system has been criticized for not being reflective of the true quality of fire protection services in many communities. Credit to ISO for listening to the criticism and for engaging the fire service in discussions about how to improve their rating program.
Below is information about the changes. I encourage you to visit their website and provide them with feedback on the proposed changes.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
ISO is embarking on a project to review and, if warranted, update the content of the Fire Suppression Rating Schedule (FSRS). Our objective for this “Draft Concept FSRS 2009” project is to identify portions of the current PPCTM evaluation worthy of potential revision.
Over the next few months, we want to engage in discussions with a variety of stakeholders in organizations that deal with water, fire, and emergency communications. We’re seeking feedback on the scope and feasibility of the possible revisions.
We offer the following draft outline of items under consideration for revision. We hope the topics will serve as a framework for feedback you may wish to give us.
Increased reference to National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standards
Possible revisions include: a requirement that, for a PPC better than 10, the fire department must have sufficient membership to assure response by at least 6 members (including the chief) to fires in structures eliminating the current ISO equipment inventory and replacing it with reference to pumper and ladder/service equipment listed in NFPA 1901 recognition of Initial Rapid Intervention Crew and Rapid Intervention Crew teams, according to NFPA 1500
an increase in minimum pump capacity for engines for Class 9 communities from 50 gpm to 250 gpm, in accordance with NFPA standards additional emphasis on firefighter safety and training:
training and credentialing for fire officers in accordance with National Incident Management System (NIMS) recommendations and NFPA 1021 training for fire apparatus drivers and operators in accordance with NFPA 1002 and 1451 no credit for training without proper documentation reference to firefighter safety requirements requirement for personal protective ensemble (PPE) clothing for all fire-suppression personnel at structure fires recognition of automatic-aid personnel responding to first-alarm structure fires extension of full credit for automatic-aid response plans to first-alarm structure fires when the departments have satisfied certain criteria for interoperability.
Below is information about the changes. I encourage you to visit their website and provide them with feedback on the proposed changes.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
ISO is embarking on a project to review and, if warranted, update the content of the Fire Suppression Rating Schedule (FSRS). Our objective for this “Draft Concept FSRS 2009” project is to identify portions of the current PPCTM evaluation worthy of potential revision.
Over the next few months, we want to engage in discussions with a variety of stakeholders in organizations that deal with water, fire, and emergency communications. We’re seeking feedback on the scope and feasibility of the possible revisions.
We offer the following draft outline of items under consideration for revision. We hope the topics will serve as a framework for feedback you may wish to give us.
Increased reference to National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) standards
Possible revisions include: a requirement that, for a PPC better than 10, the fire department must have sufficient membership to assure response by at least 6 members (including the chief) to fires in structures eliminating the current ISO equipment inventory and replacing it with reference to pumper and ladder/service equipment listed in NFPA 1901 recognition of Initial Rapid Intervention Crew and Rapid Intervention Crew teams, according to NFPA 1500
an increase in minimum pump capacity for engines for Class 9 communities from 50 gpm to 250 gpm, in accordance with NFPA standards additional emphasis on firefighter safety and training:
training and credentialing for fire officers in accordance with National Incident Management System (NIMS) recommendations and NFPA 1021 training for fire apparatus drivers and operators in accordance with NFPA 1002 and 1451 no credit for training without proper documentation reference to firefighter safety requirements requirement for personal protective ensemble (PPE) clothing for all fire-suppression personnel at structure fires recognition of automatic-aid personnel responding to first-alarm structure fires extension of full credit for automatic-aid response plans to first-alarm structure fires when the departments have satisfied certain criteria for interoperability.
Sunday, November 9, 2008
Election Results
The election is over and the voters have spoken. Regardless of whether you are republican, democrat, independent or another party, you are first, and foremost, and American. We have an obligation to support our elected leaders. If there was one thing that bothered me most about this election season, it was how negative the politics were and how easy it was for some politicians to throw our President under the bus. I don't agree with all the policies of our present Administration as I am confident I will not agree with all the policies of our new President and his Administration. But that does not mean I have to be mean spirited and attack the man because I think (from the comfort of my living room) that I could do a better job. It's not fair.
If you think you can do a better job than someone who holds and elected office, then run for that office. And if you do run for office, for God's sake, please tell me about the things you can do to make my life better (and less complicated). I don't want to hear you bash your opponent. Even if every bad thing you say about your opponent is true, it does not make me want to vote for you. I judge your behavior on the campaign trail as the behavior I can expect from you when you are in office. Don't tell me how you are a team player, a great communicator and a great problem solver, and then behave in ways that are not consistent with those qualities when dealing with your opponent. It makes you look like a hypocrite.
We are going through some tough times. Tough times do not build character, it exposes it. As a leader, people are watching you to and they take their cues from you about how to behave. Show yourself as a calm and predictable leader, worthy of the trust and confidence that your followers so desperately want to have in you.
Best wishes to our outgoing President George Bush and the members of his Administration. Thank you to Senator John McCain and Governor Sarah Palin for their desire to lead our great country. Congratulations to President-elect Barack Obama and Vice President-elect Joe Biden on a well-run campaign. I wish you much success with the challenges you will face when you take office. Your success will mean our success.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
www.RichGasaway.com
If you think you can do a better job than someone who holds and elected office, then run for that office. And if you do run for office, for God's sake, please tell me about the things you can do to make my life better (and less complicated). I don't want to hear you bash your opponent. Even if every bad thing you say about your opponent is true, it does not make me want to vote for you. I judge your behavior on the campaign trail as the behavior I can expect from you when you are in office. Don't tell me how you are a team player, a great communicator and a great problem solver, and then behave in ways that are not consistent with those qualities when dealing with your opponent. It makes you look like a hypocrite.
We are going through some tough times. Tough times do not build character, it exposes it. As a leader, people are watching you to and they take their cues from you about how to behave. Show yourself as a calm and predictable leader, worthy of the trust and confidence that your followers so desperately want to have in you.
Best wishes to our outgoing President George Bush and the members of his Administration. Thank you to Senator John McCain and Governor Sarah Palin for their desire to lead our great country. Congratulations to President-elect Barack Obama and Vice President-elect Joe Biden on a well-run campaign. I wish you much success with the challenges you will face when you take office. Your success will mean our success.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
www.RichGasaway.com
Monday, November 3, 2008
Economic Opportunities
Unless you are living under a rock, you know we are experiencing tough times. High energy costs, home foreclosures, corporate and financial industry failures, stock market downturns... it all seems like bad news. But in this bad news, there may be opportunity.
As cities begin to feel the strain of these difficult economic times, so will the fire department. For example, I believe many fire departments will be asked to take budget cuts, to reduce staffing, to cut services, downsize training, and more.
When this happens, you will be at a crossroads. You can go down the path of slash and burn, painful cuts and reduced service. Or, alternatively, you can look for new and creative ways to ensure your customer continues to get great service.
Look at the way you provide services. Do you send a full response assignment to every alarm drop? Maybe you don't have to do that. Do you bring every member in from home for every call for service? Maybe you don't have to do that. Is your department surrounded by other communities who duplicates every service you provide? Maybe it's time to strike up some regional cooperation. Or... dare I say it... mergers and consolidations. When you eliminate the duplication of services, money is saved. Money that can be put toward ensuring the residents receive the same, or improved levels of care during difficult economic times.
These challenging economic times are going to require changes in the way you do business. Do you want to be pushed and forced to change? Or do you want to be proactive and a leader of change? The time to decide is now... because the forces of change are already set in motion.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
As cities begin to feel the strain of these difficult economic times, so will the fire department. For example, I believe many fire departments will be asked to take budget cuts, to reduce staffing, to cut services, downsize training, and more.
When this happens, you will be at a crossroads. You can go down the path of slash and burn, painful cuts and reduced service. Or, alternatively, you can look for new and creative ways to ensure your customer continues to get great service.
Look at the way you provide services. Do you send a full response assignment to every alarm drop? Maybe you don't have to do that. Do you bring every member in from home for every call for service? Maybe you don't have to do that. Is your department surrounded by other communities who duplicates every service you provide? Maybe it's time to strike up some regional cooperation. Or... dare I say it... mergers and consolidations. When you eliminate the duplication of services, money is saved. Money that can be put toward ensuring the residents receive the same, or improved levels of care during difficult economic times.
These challenging economic times are going to require changes in the way you do business. Do you want to be pushed and forced to change? Or do you want to be proactive and a leader of change? The time to decide is now... because the forces of change are already set in motion.
Richard B. Gasaway, PhD, EFO, CFO
http://www.richgasaway.com/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)